Where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard, MA

  • Post last modified:May 26, 2022
You are currently viewing Where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard, MA

Martha’s Vineyard is one of the most classic American destinations. The New England island offers stunning scenery and all the comforts you crave for. But where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard for the best experience?

The most popular places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard are Edgartown and Oak Bluffs. Other options for where to stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard are Vineyard Haven and the Up-Island area.

This travel site can exist thanks to compensation from advertising and affiliate links. Find out more here.

Find places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard

Edgartown – Peaceful easternmost Martha’s Vineyard accommodation

Edgartown, Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven occupy the eastern portion of Martha’s Vineyard. In the so called Down-Island region Edgartown is the easternmost option for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard.

The quaint town is characterized by its countless historic white-painted homes. Many of the elegant homes in Greek Revival style were built by ship captains in the 1800s when Edgartown was a whaling center.

In the quintessential New England setting the town offers delightful Martha’s Vineyard hotels, dining and shops. It’s certainly a town in Martha’s Vineyard that has all the amenities you crave for.

With its peaceful easternmost location Edgartown is also home to several iconic beaches. A short ride from Martha’s Vineyard lodging in Edgartown two celebrated beach spots are Joseph Sylvia State Beach and South Beach.

For even more secluded beaches Chappaquiddick Island to the east of the town is a popular day trip destination. To get there you just need to take a short ferry ride from the harbor in Edgartown.

But with the exclusive setting and location comes higher rates at Martha’s Vineyard hotels in Edgartown. So if you travel on a budget, you should look towards the other alternatives for where to stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard.

To sum up, Edgartown is an option for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard that ticks every box for a relaxing stay. On the island’s eastern end the town offers both a peaceful setting and some of the best hotels on Martha’s Vineyard.

Pick Edgartown for: Peaceful Martha’s Vineyard lodging.

Recommended Martha’s Vineyard hotels in Edgartown

Harbor View Hotel – Luxury Martha’s Vineyard accommodation

Harbor View Hotel offers jaw-dropping views over Edgartown Lighthouse and the harbor. With a location between downtown Edgartown and the beach the luxury Martha’s Vineyard resort also gives you easy access to both.

In addition to the location, amenities including a seasonal pool makes a stay as comfortable as it gets. It’s certainly easy to see why Harbor View Hotel constantly is ranked as one of the best places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard.

White lighthouse on Martha's Vineyard
The lighthouse in Edgartown.

Oak Bluffs – Martha’s Vineyard hotels in a livelier town

Among the three Down-Island towns Oak Bluffs is located west of Edgartown but east of Vineyard Haven. It’s an alternative for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard that’s known to offer more liveliness than the other island towns.

In Oak Bluffs you find much of the island’s buzz. During the summer season the downtown area in Oak Bluffs, where you also find many Martha’s Vineyard hotels, really wakes to life.

For entertainment Circuit Avenue with its shops, restaurants and bars is the centre of activity. In the outgoing downtown area you more often than not find something fun going on.

Across Oak Bluffs the town’s signature gingerbread cottages in various colors contribute to the fun vibe. Once built for camp meetings, you find approximately 300 colorful cottages in the heart of the Martha’s Vineyard town.

Just a stone’s throw away from the active downtown area the Oak Bluffs beach also calls for attention. Conveniently so at many of the town’s Martha’s Vineyard hotels and inns you’re just steps from the easily accessible beach.

In conclusion, Oak Bluffs is the best alternative for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard if you look for a lively town. But if you prefer something quieter, you should look towards the other options for where to stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard.

Pick Oak Bluffs for: A livelier Martha’s Vineyard stay.

Recommended Martha’s Vineyard hotels in Oak Bluffs

Inkwell Beach Cottage – Beachfront Martha’s Vineyard lodging

Inkwell Beach Cottage, formerly Isabelle’s Beach House, is the beach bum’s favorite. With the inviting dunes just across the street the beachfront Martha’s Vineyard lodging has a stunning location.

In the other direction Inkwell Beach Cottage also offers easy access to the heart of Oak Bluffs. From the oceanfront Martha’s Vineyard bed and breakfast it’s just 10 minutes by foot to Circuit Avenue.

The Oak Bluffs Inn – A Martha’s Vineyard inn on Circuit Avenue

When it comes to access to Oak Bluffs entertainment, you can’t beat the Oak Bluffs Inn. On Circuit Avenue, the main drag in Oak Bluffs, the Martha’s Vineyard place to stay has restaurants and stores on its doorstep.

Although centrally located the Oak Bluffs Inn still manages to keep its peaceful home away from home atmosphere. Its cozy front porch is certainly a nice feature that adds to the welcoming vibe.

Colorful gingerbread cottage on Martha's Vineyard
Gingerbread cottage in Oak Bluffs.

Vineyard Haven – Stay in the gateway town on Martha’s Vineyard

On top of Edgartown and Oak Bluffs a third main population center on the island is Vineyard Haven. Also known as Tisbury, the town is the westernmost in the Down-Island area.

Most notably Vineyard Haven is the only town on Martha’s Vineyard with a year-round ferry service. Every month of the year excited visitors arrive in Vineyard Haven from the mainland.

As one of the bigger towns on the island Vineyard Haven is also home to a dynamic commercial district. On Main Street you find an appreciated selection of stores, restaurants and Martha’s Vineyard accommodation.

But even though Vineyard Haven is such a practical town, many visitors fall for the appeal of Martha’s Vineyard hotels in Edgartown and Oak Bluffs. Therefore you often find cheaper hotels on Martha’s Vineyard in the gateway town.

In conclusion, Vineyard Haven is a convenient option for where to stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard. Additionally the year-round town is also a great alternative for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard on a budget.

Pick Vineyard Haven for: Convenient Martha’s Vineyard accommodation.

Up-Island – The most secluded Martha’s Vineyard places to stay

The Up-Island area of Martha’s Vineyard is the western part of the island. It’s the option for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard that’s located away from the mainland ferry connections and the island’s busier communities.

From east to west the towns West Tisbury, Chilmark and Aquinnah are located in the Up-Island region. These rural Martha’s Vineyard towns are much smaller and quieter than the towns further east on the island.

Most hotels on Martha’s Vineyard are also located further east on the island. In the Up-Island area you find an in general very limited selection of Martha’s Vineyard lodging, dining and things to do.

Still it’s the peacefulness that is the big draw of the westernmost part of Martha’s Vineyard. In the island’s western region you find mile after mile of empty beaches to enjoy.

All in all, the Up-Island alternative for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard offers a seclusion that you don’t find anywhere else. But if you prefer to have entertainment near, you should look towards the places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard further east.

Pick Up-Island for: Secluded Martha’s Vineyard places to stay.

Colorful sunset on Martha's Vineyard
Sunset on Martha’s Vineyard.

Search for hotels on Martha’s Vineyard

Use the booking tool below to find the best places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard. Browse the map for options in various areas, or click on the search button to get all Martha’s Vineyard hotels listed.

Booking.com

Where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard FAQ

Here you find the answers to some frequently asked questions about where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts.

Can I stay on Martha’s Vineyard?

There’s a wide selection of hotels, motels, inns and other lodging on Martha’s Vineyard. In the island’s charming towns you find places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard for every traveler.

Where should I stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard?

Edgartown and Oak Bluffs are the most popular options for where to stay on Martha’s Vineyard. In the two eastern towns you find a quintessential vibe and several great Martha’s Vineyard hotels. Other alternatives for where to stay when visiting Martha’s Vineyard are Vineyard Haven and the quieter Up-Island.

Which is the nicest part of Martha’s Vineyard?

The two main parts of Martha’s Vineyard offer very different experiences. Down-Island is the busier part of Martha’s Vineyard where the island’s three biggest towns are located. Up-Island is more secluded with fewer things to do and thinner crowds.

Which is better Edgartown or Oak Bluffs?

Edgartown is famous for its white-painted houses and Oak Bluffs for its colorful gingerbread cottages. Both towns certainly offer the comforts you crave for including quality Martha’s Vineyard lodging. However, Oak Bluffs is known as the livelier one among the Martha’s Vineyard places to stay.

Which is better Oak Bluffs or Vineyard Haven?

Oak Bluffs attracts visitors with its colorful cottages, iconic beach and lively Circuit Avenue. Vineyard Haven is the island’s main port of entry with superb restaurants and shops on Main Street. As it’s just a few miles between the two places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard, you can easily go between them.

Are there any Martha’s Vineyard hotels on the beach?

Most hotels on Martha’s Vineyard are located close to a beach. Still it’s certainly something extra with direct beach access, and you get that at the recommended Inkwell Beach Cottage. At the celebrated oceanfront Martha’s Vineyard bed and breakfast you have the beach just steps away.

Are there any hotels on Chappaquiddick Island?

There are no hotels on Chappaquiddick Island. Instead most visitors stay a short ferry ride away on Martha’s Vineyard and day trip to Chappaquiddick. In Edgartown you find many hotels near Chappaquiddick Island.

Continue reading

Cape Cod vacation guide >

Where to stay in Cape Cod >

The best Nantucket places to stay >